Research Guides
Check What a Research Demo Never Says Out Loud
A product demo can show exactly what happened without saying enough for a reader to verify it. If the presenter says “that worked,” but only the screen shows which setting changed, the spoken track does not carry the claim. Test the clip by listening before you decide what detail needs a description.
1. Start with the claim the clip is supposed to prove
Write the claim down before pressing play. Keep it narrow: “Changing the date range from seven days to thirty changes the report total” is easier to check than “The reporting tool is flexible.” Note the time range and the exact facts a reader needs: what was selected, what changed, and which conditions still apply.
2. Listen first, then check the screen
Look away during a first pass and write down what you can recover from the audio alone. On a second pass, watch the same segment. Mark anything visible but not spoken that changes the claim. In a fictional traffic dashboard at 00:38, the presenter says “now it’s 240.” The screen shows a 30-day filter and labels the metric “sessions.” Without those words, 240 could mean visitors, clicks, or a total over another period. A better narration line is “With the last 30 days selected, the report shows 240 sessions.” If the labels still aren’t visible or readable in the original, don’t invent them.
3. Put the missing information where the reader uses it
For footage you own, build the facts into the main narration when possible. For a finished clip, identify a pause where a description can be heard without covering meaningful speech, or use a described version. The W3C explanation of prerecorded audio description covers important visuals that are missing from the original audio and explains that redundant narration isn’t needed when the audio already conveys the information. For a third-party embed you can’t edit, put the timestamp and the observed evidence beside the player, label it as a summary, and check whether the resulting article stands on its own. Don’t treat the summary as proof that the clip meets the Level AA audio description criterion.
Copy this review row
Time range | claim | what the audio says | visual-only detail | correction | retest result
Retest with someone who has not seen the clip. If they can name the metric, value, and time range in the example without looking, the repaired narration carries the evidence. If they still have to guess, leave the finding open. For the opposite playback check, read Test the Captions on an Embedded Research Video.