Research Guides
Check Whether a Research Draft Survives Signing In Again
Signing back in proves that a reviewer regained access. It does not prove that the half-written comparison, selected sources or review step survived. Test what comes back after the session expires, not just whether the sign-in page works.
W3C’s explanation of WCAG 2.2 Re-authenticating describes a Level AAA criterion: after re-authenticating, a person should be able to continue the activity without losing the data already entered. That is not a recommendation to relax authentication or leave private drafts visible while signed out.
1. Make a small, distinguishable fixture
In a test workspace, create a fictional comparison with a short unsaved note, two differently named sources and a selected review step. Change one value after the last save, so a tester can tell the difference between the saved version and the current work. Record which values ought to persist under the documented rules. Do not use real customer notes or production credentials.
2. Run four separate cases
- Same reviewer returns: allow the test session to expire normally or use the test environment’s supported expiry control. Sign in as the same reviewer and compare each field and the step that opens. Do not count a bare redirect to the workspace as recovery.
- Sign-in is abandoned: leave the test flow before completing sign-in. Check that the signed-out view does not disclose the private fixture. Record what the interface says will happen to the draft.
- A different test identity signs in: use a dedicated second test identity. The first person’s private draft must not appear. Confirm the identity before resuming work.
- The saved and working versions differ: put different harmless values in the last saved draft and the current edits. Check that a recovery screen accurately identifies what it restored, rather than implying that older saved text includes the last edits.
3. Record what actually returned
Use one row per item: field or step | saved value | value immediately before expiry | value after sign-in | pass, fail or not tested. For example, if “Reasons to recheck the claim” returns but the second citation selection does not, mark prose and citations separately. Distinguish restoring a draft from sending, sharing or submitting it. A restored form should not silently count as a new submission.
This worksheet checks one recovery path, not overall accessibility, account security or live capabilities of Colquhoun.shop. For the separate question of whether an interrupted submission already ran, see the research retry decision guide.