Research Guides
Give Research Text Room to Breathe Without Hiding Evidence
A carefully sourced article is less useful if its caveats disappear when a reader adjusts the text. A neat card at the default spacing can clip its last sentence under a different reading preference. Review the evidence as well as the appearance.
This is a focused editorial QA worksheet for HTML research pages. It is not a full accessibility audit, legal certification or an SEO ranking prediction. It does not describe an automated Colquhoun.shop feature.
1. Choose a meaningful sample
Pick an article with a long heading, a short note, source links and a control such as a filter or expandable explanation if one exists. Record the page revision, browser, viewport and original presentation. Use a local test copy or temporary browser styling rather than changing production just to run a check.
For an invented competitor study, choose the card that says its review sample includes only recent complaints. That qualification matters more than whether all the cards stay the same height.
2. Apply a documented spacing test
W3C's Text Spacing explanation gives four settings for supported markup: line height of at least 1.5 times the font size, space after paragraphs of at least twice the font size, letter spacing of at least 0.12 times the font size and word spacing of at least 0.16 times the font size. Apply them together without changing other style properties for this test. These are not mandatory default design values; the point is avoiding loss of content or function when a reader overrides spacing. Language and script exceptions apply where a property is not used. W3C: Text Spacing
Record how the styles were applied and confirm they actually reached the sampled text. An override that never takes effect is an inconclusive test, not a pass.
3. Read the evidence again
Compare the before and after views sentence by sentence around the claim, limitation and source. Look for clipped final lines, overlapping headings, labels that cover values and buttons whose names no longer fit. If text is shortened visually, check whether a usable mechanism still exposes the full content.
In the invented study, losing “recent complaints only” changes the apparent scope of the research. Write a defect as “the sampling qualification is hidden after spacing changes,” not simply “card alignment looks bad.” Capture the affected passage and the settings that reproduce it.
4. Keep spacing and reflow checks distinct
Text spacing tests changed spacing. Narrow-screen or zoom checks ask different layout questions. W3C's Reflow criterion addresses presenting content without loss and without unnecessary two-dimensional scrolling at specified equivalent dimensions, with exceptions for content needing a two-dimensional layout. Do not use success in one check as evidence that the other passed. W3C: Reflow
For the adjacent content-completeness review, use the mobile content parity worksheet. Record untested combinations separately instead of calling the entire site accessible.
5. Close with a reusable record
- Sample: URL, revision and important qualification.
- Setup: browser, viewport, spacing settings and application method.
- Result: content retained, controls usable, and any clipped or overlapping text.
- Repair: affected component, responsible owner and retest evidence.
- Limits: other languages, pages or assistive technology combinations not checked.
After a repair, repeat the same setup and restore the default view to check for regressions. Keep the acceptance statement specific to the sample. A useful research page gives readers room to adjust its presentation without taking away the information that makes its claims interpretable.