Research Guides
Record Histogram Boundaries Before Comparing Website Data
Two website reports show different-looking distributions of article length. Before concluding that the content changed, check whether the charts use the same intervals. A histogram's grouping choices belong in the research record, not just in a charting application's hidden settings.
This worksheet is for a manual review of numeric website measurements. It uses invented values and does not describe a Colquhoun.shop histogram feature.
1. Name the measurement and the grouping
NIST describes a common histogram as counts of observations within equal-sized intervals, or bins. It also distinguishes ordinary counts from normalized versions, including proportions and density. Those choices change what the vertical axis means. NIST: Histogram
Record the measured variable, unit and included population. For article length, explain whether navigation, comments and reference lists are counted. An interval definition cannot rescue a comparison built from inconsistent measurements.
2. Make boundary membership explicit
Consider five fictional word counts: 480, 500, 520, 980 and 1000. Define intervals as 0 to less than 500, 500 to less than 1000, and 1000 to less than 1500. The counts are one, three and one.
If the labels instead say only “0–500” and “500–1000,” a reader cannot tell where a value of exactly 500 belongs. State the endpoint convention and test a value exactly on a boundary. Each included observation should enter one interval, not two or none.
Keep the ungrouped measurements. Once values have been reduced to interval totals, another reviewer cannot reliably reconstruct the original records or apply a different grouping.
3. Hold the chart settings steady for a comparison
When comparing two releases, use the same interval boundaries and axis meaning for the main paired view. Record changes to the page population separately. A chart with twice as many observations can have taller count bars without indicating that individual pages became longer.
If the research question concerns proportions rather than totals, label that view accordingly and retain the sample sizes. Do not alternate between counts and percentages while keeping the same unlabeled vertical axis.
As an additional exploratory check, inspect another reasonable interval width. If a headline depends on one particular grouping, report that sensitivity instead of selecting only the most dramatic picture. Keep the main comparison reproducible even when supplementary views explore alternatives.
4. Reconcile observations before interpreting shape
Sum the interval counts and compare the result with the number of included numeric observations. Account separately for unavailable measurements, excluded records and values outside the displayed range. Do not let a cropped chart silently remove the longest pages.
Investigate unexpected concentrations by returning to individual records. A large group at a round number might be genuine, or it might reflect a measurement limit or rounding rule. The chart identifies a question; it does not answer that question on its own.
5. Copy this histogram settings card
- Variable: definition, unit and collection method.
- Population: included records and observation period.
- Intervals: complete boundaries and endpoint convention.
- Vertical axis: count, proportion or another explicitly defined measure.
- Coverage: included, unavailable, excluded and out-of-range counts.
- Comparison: settings held constant and any supplementary views.
- Conclusion: visible pattern and unresolved explanations.
Attach the settings card to the figure or its accompanying research notes. Another analyst should be able to reproduce the totals without guessing how the software chose its bins.
The acceptance criterion is an interpretable distribution with a traceable population. It is not a preferred article length, a ranking target or proof that one content strategy is superior.