Research Guides
Review a Search Sitelink as a Reader Shortcut
A shortcut under a search result can expose a navigation problem that is easy to miss from the homepage. The label may sound useful while the destination opens an outdated guide, an unclear landing page or a section intended for a different audience.
Review the reader's route before proposing a search-display fix. This worksheet is for manual research on a site you control or are authorized to inspect. It does not describe a Colquhoun.shop feature for selecting search sitelinks.
1. Capture the shortcut in context
Record the query, result page URL, observation date, displayed shortcut text and exact destination. Save a screenshot when permitted. Keep each observation separate: different queries or later checks should not overwrite the original evidence.
Google describes sitelinks as same-domain links grouped beneath a text result. Their selection is automated and depends on whether the system considers them useful for the query. A site owner cannot treat a preferred shortcut list as a guaranteed search layout. Google: Sitelinks
If a colleague reports a missing shortcut without a query or screenshot, mark the observation incomplete. Do not infer a site-wide change from an undocumented recollection.
2. Test the promise made by the label
Open the destination and write down what a visitor can actually do there. Compare that with the displayed wording. Check whether an introductory explanation, current content or an obvious next step is missing.
In an invented example, “Research methods” leads to an old event announcement that happens to contain those words. The event page still has historical value, but it does not answer a reader seeking the publication's current methodology. That is a specific destination mismatch, not evidence that the entire site should be reorganized.
Keep the search observation and the editorial assessment in separate fields. The first describes what was displayed; the second explains why the destination did or did not fulfill the reader's likely task.
3. Inspect the route you control
Find how the intended destination is linked from relevant site pages. Record the label and surrounding context rather than merely counting links. Identify confusingly similar page names and abandoned paths that could mislead visitors regardless of search presentation.
Google's guidance recommends a logical site structure, relevant internal links, informative compact titles and headings, and concise relevant anchor text. These are site improvements to evaluate, not a recipe that guarantees a particular sitelink.
For the fictional publication, a defensible proposal is to give the current methodology page a clear name and an appropriate route from the research section. Preserve the historical event's identity instead of relabeling it as the current method just to match a desired shortcut.
4. Keep removal decisions separate
Do not casually delete a useful page or exclude it from search solely to tidy a screenshot. First ask what purpose the page still serves, who uses it and what the owner actually wants to change. Record the consequences and obtain the appropriate authorization before altering availability or indexing controls.
A request for clearer navigation is not automatically a request to remove historical material. Leave unresolved editorial decisions open instead of hiding them inside a technical fix.
5. Close with two outcomes
- Observed shortcut: query, wording, destination and date.
- Reader task: what the destination should help someone accomplish.
- Site issue: concrete content or navigation mismatch.
- Authorized change: exact page or link adjustment.
- Site verification: public destination and navigation retested.
- Search follow-up: later display observation, unchanged or not yet checked.
Report the navigation improvement as complete only when verified. Report a search-display change only when observed. Keeping those outcomes separate prevents a useful site repair from becoming an unsupported promise about Google's next result.