Research Guides
Test the Section Link, Not Just the Research Page
A citation can open the right article and still leave the reader searching for the evidence. Section links help when they land beside the passage that supports a claim. They become misleading when a redesign removes the target or a rewritten section no longer says what the citation suggests.
This checklist is for ordinary HTML heading links, not a complete accessibility audit or a guarantee of stable third-party content. Keep the page-level citation as well as the specific passage you checked.
1. Record the intended target
In an invented pricing review, a link to /plans/#usage-limits should help a reader find the usage limits, not simply open the plans page. Write down the claim, full link, visible heading and date checked. Include a short paraphrase of the relevant condition, such as whether a limit is per account or per workspace.
MDN explains that the fragment after # is handled by the client, not sent with the server request. In HTML, it can identify an element by its ID. That is why a successful HTTP response alone does not establish that a section link works. MDN: URI fragment
2. Follow the link as a reader
Open the full URL in a fresh tab. Note where the page lands, whether the intended heading exists and whether a sticky header hides the start of the passage. Repeat on a narrow screen. If the page needs loading or interaction before the section appears, record that dependency rather than marking the citation universally reliable.
Then read the passage. A working anchor is not evidence that the claim remains true. If the section says limits vary by plan, a citation supporting one universal limit needs editorial correction, even when the link lands perfectly.
3. Make the destination clear before the click
Use a label such as “Plan usage limits” instead of several identical “read more” links. W3C’s explanation of link purpose says readers should be able to determine a link’s purpose from its text or its programmatically associated context. This does not mean every citation needs a long URL as its visible label. W3C: Link Purpose in Context
In the invented review, keep the plan name and billing condition next to the citation. A clear label cannot rescue an unsupported comparison, but it can make checking that comparison easier.
4. Protect targets on pages you own
Before renaming a heading or reorganizing an article, search your own pages for links to its existing ID. Where practical, keep a meaningful stable target while revising the visible heading. Check that IDs are unique and that any retained target still points to the same subject. Do not preserve an old anchor by silently sending readers to unrelated material.
For external pages, you cannot promise permanence. Save the source context using the research handoff checklist and recheck high-value citations when updating your article.
5. Copy this acceptance note
- Claim: what the citation is supporting.
- Destination: page URL, fragment and intended heading.
- Observed result: landing location and whether the passage supports the claim.
- Reader checks: descriptive label, narrow-screen visibility and route back to the article.
- Follow-up: owner, change needed and date for a recheck.
Close with a bounded result: “The sampled link reached the usage-limits passage at the recorded settings, and the cited condition matched.” Keep untested devices and later source changes outside that conclusion. A reliable citation is a small reader journey, not just a green status code.